Is it a “good” design? Estimated toughness by comparing manufacturer’s testing, in combination with the estimated CATRA values, allows us an educated guess for the toughness-edge retention combination for the steels allowing for easy comparison: There is also a trendline, which is simply an averaged line drawn through all of the steels. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. M390 has only slightly lower toughness than K390 with similar carbide volume (though K390 was tested at 62 Rc). Knife Category Double Action OTF Blade Steel Bohler ELMAX® or M390 or 204P Weight 3.2 oz Blade Length Depend on the user demands and requirements, one type of steel will look more promising than the others. And the datasheet shows that the toughness of M398 is only about a third of M390, though at somewhat higher hardness: Comparing with other Bohler steels, you can see that the toughness of M398 is quite low. it reduces the amount of “vanadium carbide”, some Bohler-patented high wear resistance steels using niobium instead. He also has a custom heat treat protocol, Your email address will not be published. 4-position. For the steels that we have experimental values for, these predictions are close. Bohler Uddeholm M390. For the steels that we have experimental values for, these predictions are close. S35VN Stahl besteht aus 1,4 Prozent Kohlenstoff, 14 Prozent Chrom… Minor surprises are usually in the area of toughness, in my previous comparison of CATRA edge retention steels usually end up where you expect them to be based on their carbide content. Chaves 229 M390 vs Protech FF Mordax 20CV edge retention testing, one surprise along with a let down - Duration: 15:35. “New Bohler powder metallurgy high speed steel with excellent hot hardness.” In Proc. 0.145" (3.7mm) Handle. 100% Upvoted. The addition of niobium is reflected with the … You can read about how that equation was derived in this article. However, the Elmax2 steel seems to do as well as the high carbide Vanadis 60 high speed steel. - TWISTED SISAL SHIRTS etc Subscribe and hit the bell! Below I will use the available information to come up with as good a comparison we can with other stainless steels in its class. Which test? Post by Sumdumguy » Tue Sep 04, 2018 12:17 am . S45VN is a king when it comes to field sharpening. a mix) of carbon and iron that is often enriched with other elements to improve certain characteristics depending on the desired application. M390 is a better steel but N690 is still very good. M390 Steel. To show the stark difference here are some non-stainless Crucible PM steels overlaid on the above chart: I’m personally not all that interested in yet another high edge retention steel that sacrifices toughness, ease in sharpening, and workability. Steel is essentially an alloy (i.e. Hope that this helps. 20cvクラスの鋼材として他にm390とcts204pがあるそうです。 s45vnはまだレビューが多くありません。 388 名前なカッター(ノ∀`) 2020/08/02(日) 20:28:31.66 id:0oqdazxm. First up, S45VN Para 3. However, after all of these comparisons I can’t help but be disappointed that the steel companies appear to still be stuck on very high carbide volume stainless steels when using powder metallurgy. Closed Length. Sure, there is a performance difference I can see that but to justify that much in cost difference? Follow me on Instagram@keithkevinken. Top. So M398 doesn’t appear to be over-performing relative to its composition and carbide content. Jun 29, 1999 . 3.8" long blade, 9.50" overall tip down carry. The other steels in the previous chart such as S110V, S90V, and S125V are relatively different from M398 but are similar when it comes to total carbide volume fraction and level of wear resistance. And for Vanax I showed only the total carbide volume because I didn’t want to add another column for its vanadium nitrides, which are different than vanadium carbides. S35VN D2; EDGE RETENTION: 6/10: 3.5/10: EASE OF SHARPNESS: 6/10: 4/10: CORROSION … Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Dec 12, 2017 #1. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Ok so browsing Aliexpress I see some folders marked as either M390 or S35VN …. Many steels are high hardness (ZDP-189, M390) and many are high toughness (3V, INFI, and Vanadis 4 Extra) but no steel really matches M4 in its combination of the two. When it comes to a knife, everybody wants a durable, flexible and long lasting product. These comparisons will have a range of accuracy. Roughly comparable steels include S60V, MPL-1 (also called Supracor), and “Elmax2” which is an unreleased, patented stainless steel from Uddeholm that I have named Elmax2 because they haven’t named it. N/A. Uddeholm recently replaced their Vanadis 6 and Vanadis 10 steels with a new Vanadis 8 which was designed to eliminate chromium carbides present in the older versions to improve overall properties. Sure, there is a performance difference I can see that but to justify that much in cost difference? MARKET … M390 exhibits excellent edge retention, corrosion resistance, and high level toughness. KnifeCenter or BladeHQ carry these special production runs or are the Dealers limited to DLT Trading, Bento Box Shop? The Para 3 has the Spyderco compression lock, a full flat ground blade, and killer ergos. Both Bohler and Uddeholm use an unnotched Izod toughness test with a 7 x 10 x 55 mm specimen. Today in this article, you can learn some interesting information about two premium blade steels: CTS-XHP vs. M390. [9] Kajinic, Alqjz, Robert B. Dixon, and Brian A. Hann. Along the same lines, CPM S45VN has slightly better edge retention in CATRA test results (all % numbers relative to AISA 440C steel ) when compared to S35VN steel , 143% vs, 140%, and slightly worse than S30V steel - 145%. CPM 15V, known for its excessive amount of wear resistance, has 23-25% carbide volume of all vanadium carbide, while M398 has a full 5% more than 15V. There is no such thing as the best steel, each got their own pros and cons. Therefore, even if a higher impact toughness value is measured I would not recommend heat treating the steel in that way. 3.0 out of 5 stars 2. S90V and S110V are close, however, but with significantly lower carbide volume which could mean that they have superior toughness to M398. Sheath. This premium "super steel" is used in many Benchmade knives and several Hinderer and Zero Tolerance models. [10] Kajinic, Alojz, Andrzej Wojcieszynski, and Maria Sawford. The steel is only available in Russia right now as far as I know, and the datasheet currently available is in Russian [1]. I ended up going with a first production CPM Cruwear Bravo 1 in green canvas micarta, with hollow pins so it will have more utilitarian use. Das Featureset der AMD Radeon R9 M380 umfasst u.a. Benchmark your GPU here. : S30V/S35VN or S110V or M390 . 10% off. They have the ELMAX Version in stock, but the M390 is out of stock or available for pre-order depending on which site. Sumdumguy Member Posts: 3160 Joined: Sun Dec 03, 2017 9:51 pm. NVIDIA VS AMD BOTTLENECK Effective Speed +17% Real World Speed. Para Military™ 2 G-10 Dark Blue CPM S110V . The compression lock is a very desirable feature and the entire knife is built super tough. NEWOOTZ EDC Folding Pocket Knife with Leather Sheath,Bohler M390 High-Speed Steel Slim 4in Blade,Ironwood or Titanium Handle with Lock,Tanto Style Gentleman's Knife for Men. I’m the first owner on all 3 of these knives. Die Zahl 35 dient aber lediglich zur Unterscheidung vom CPM S30V. 17 comments. Do all Dealers, e.g. Like ELMAX, it is just as tough as, if not tougher than, S35VN, and can hold an extremely strong and sharp edge. Since the steel is brand new and largely not available we couldn’t do any experimental comparisons even if we had the money and time to do so. My next step is going to be a custom puukko. I want the larger version so 0560, 0561,0562. … One way we evaluate powder metallurgy steels is with the carbide volume numbers. He is a YouTuber from the United States. So we can understand more the Steel, let’s see its chemical composition. Rhodies. Discussion in 'Maintenance, Tinkering & Embellishment' started by Rhodies, Dec 12, 2017. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Spyderco Baby Jess Horn … save hide report. For a given volume of carbide, wear resistance is maximized by having the hardest carbides possible, which are usually vanadium carbides. RWL34 is easier to sharpen but doesn't hold an edge as well as the other two in general, especially M390 (assuming proper heat treatment across all of them). Trader. Either that or im making a couple in CPM m4 or m390. Are these "Exclusive Dealer Runs" ever announced beforehand? However, quite a bit of information is available in the datasheet, allowing us to have a pretty good understanding of the properties that the steel has. Thank you! S35VN M390; EDGE RETENTION: 6/10: 8/10: EASE OF SHARPNESS: 6/10: 5/10: CORROSION RESISTANCE: 7/10: 8/10: TOUGHNESS: 6/10: 6/10: M390 has higher edge retention, and the same level of toughness with higher corrosion resistance compared to S35VN steel. CTS-204P. Here is a chart of Crucible steels showing the effect of carbide volume on toughness: So the carbide volume fraction is very important for steel design and predicting steel properties. Thanks for the help everyone! Die Buchstaben “S”, “V” und “N” beziehen sich auf die Begriffe “rostfrei”, “Vanadium” und “Niob”. [11] Sadberg, Odd and Lennart Jonsson. It will just take a bit longer to make. Get it as soon as Thu, Dec 3. G-10. NVIDIA VS AMD BOTTLENECK Effective Speed +7% Real World Speed. Double action Out the Front (OTF) knife. So in terms of maximizing the wear resistance-toughness balance we don’t expect M398 to break any new ground. [1] To see how the different carbide types and carbide fraction affects edge retention read this article. Sort by. What it is: M390 stainless steel, a powder-metallurgy material produced by Bohler-Uddeholm, is widely regarded as a "super steel" for its properties and performance. Thanks! Order yours today with our always free shipping. CPM S35VN (Datenblatt: hier) ist ein hochwertiger Edelstahl, der Teil der “SxxV-Serie” von Crucible Industries ist. Henrysears February 11, 2020 Blog No Comments. It's comparable to Bohler's M390 stainless steel or Carpenter's CTS-204P and, like those alloys, takes a mirrored finish well. There will likely be other M390 runs. 390 390X Fury-X Fury Nano. DLT is smack dab in the middle of the exclusives market and has brought out some of the hottest models over the last few years such as the Paramilitary 2 Red G-10 M390 Blade and the Paramilitary 2 Tan 20CV blade series. Bird & Trout CPM S45VN Blackwater 2 Elmax Bloke X Bloke X V2 Bloke Z V2 Boone 1 A2 Bravo 1 A2 Bravo 1 Custom Köcher-Scheide Bravo 1 Custom Sabot Scheide Bravo 1 Field A2 Bravo 1 LT CPM 3V Bravo 1.2 A2 (German Edition) Bravo 1.5 A2 Bravo 1.5 LT CPM 3V Bravo Necker 1 CPM 154 Bravo Necker 2 CPM 154 BRKCA Knife 2017 CPM 3V Brokk A2 Brunox Lubri-Food Bush Seax Bantam A2 … “Corrosion resistant, high vanadium, powder metallurgy tool steel articles with improved metal to metal wear resistance and a method for producing the same.” U.S. Patent 5,936,169, issued August 10, 1999. S35VN & M390 . Kershaw Knockout 1870CFM390 Carbon Fiber M390. Bear in mind, I am basing the cost difference using eBay as a source since I don't think Spyderco no longer sells the Para 2 in m390. ON CATRA’s TCC test, M390 scored higher than S35VN, at 959, whereas S35Vn scored a 707. Alongside edge geometry and design, blade steel is a critical element that determines how a knife performs. Either that or im making a couple in CPM m4 or m390. I have beater knives, so light duty is the most I'd use it for. M390. Crucible’s first major stainless […] You can read about why those directions are important in this article on toughness. Right now is a poor time to buy an M390 PM2. $112.45 $ 112. Using the reported carbide numbers from M398 along with other steels we can use a simple equation to predict the approximate edge retention of different steels. 284. Battle Worn Finish!! The end result is that Uddeholm toughness values are somewhat lower than those for Bohler, particularly for low carbide volumes: You can also see that Elmax and Vanax steels underperform the non-stainless trendline of Vanadis 4 Extra (V4E) and Vanadis 8. Microtech Ultratech is a double action, button fired automatic knife. „Eyefinity“ Technologie, die je nach Schnittstellen Gegebenheiten die Nutzung von bis zu 6 Bildschirmen simultan er The... $129.95. And M398 has quite a bit less toughness than that: So it is apparent that the design of M398 is all about wear resistance and essentially ignores toughness. Less chromium in solution means lower corrosion resistance, which is confirmed by the corrosion test that they did: So overall, M398 has higher wear resistance and hardness than M390, but lower toughness and corrosion resistance. Para Military™ 2 G-10 Black. More carbide means less toughness, so the lower the volume of carbide the better the toughness is. The end result is that Elmax2 has similar toughness to the original Elmax, a fact that surprised the designers of the steel [11]. Spyderco Para Military 3 Sprint Run C223GPFGR, 2.95" CPM S45VN Plain Blade, G-10 Handle. It also performs well with both coarse and highly polished edges. According to some manufacturers and knife makers, the 20CV is the best of the three at holding an edge. The design goal for Uddeholm, Bohler, and Crucible is generally the same for cold work tool steels and stainless steels: maximize vanadium carbide content. It will give you everything you are looking for, but be prepared to pay between $250.00 and $300.00 with the scalpers on eBay. Both are great steels and very close in real life performance, IMHO. Benchmark your GPU here. Intel® Core™ i3-390M Processor (3M Cache, 2.66 GHz) quick reference guide including specifications, features, pricing, compatibility, design documentation, ordering codes, spec codes and more. *THIS IS THE GLASS BREAKER VERSION- S90V, S110V, and S125V appear to offer a superior combination of properties to the new M398. CPM® S45VN is a martensitic stainless steel specifically created to transcend its predecessors. Re: Which PM2? “Alternative materials for high-temperature and high-pressure valves.” (2010). Any thoughts/suggesions much appreciated. CPM® S45VN is a martensitic stainless steel specifically created to transcend its predecessors. Toughness Test K390 vs Cruwear vs S110V. United States. M390 did offer similar toughness to the cold-work tool steels like K390 with a similar carbide volume, but M398 has significantly lower toughness than the similar carbide volume S290. “Wear and corrosion resistant PM tool steels for advanced bearing applications.” In Bearing steel technology. I really do wish M390, CTS204P and Elmax would become standard instead of just sprint runs. For MPL-1 the breakdown of its carbide types is not known, only the total volume, so I assumed all of it is the vanadium-enriched chromium carbide. VS. YouTube *NEW* About 93 13,642 BUY • $325 Release date: Q2 2015. While they have similar histories and composition, there are a few. The bulk Cr content in M398 is the same as M390 but the amount of chromium carbide increased from 18% to 25%, which also tells us that chromium in solution has been reduced. This high-performance alloy offers very high wear and corrosion resistance, yet remains extremely easy to sharpen and maintain. S35VN VS D2. Steels that are above the trendline show a superior combination of properties and those below it have a somewhat lower toughness-edge retention balance. This thing is SO beautiful, and the sheath is as well. Bento Box Shop had their blue exclusive PM2 for something like $195 shipped, DLT Trading did their red exclusive for I think $145. So, eBay would really be a poor choice cause their prices are all over the map. Hope your enjoying this mini series of all the knives that I bought in 2019. Buy Spyderco Paramilitary 2 Folding Knives, Spyderco Knives' Paramilitary 2 pocket knife models are some of the most sought after. Spyderco Baby Jess Horn G-10 CX08GGYP, 2.60 in VG-10 Plain Blade, Sprint Run. AMD Radeon R9 M390. They have been released with some of the finest blade steels and handle materials. This Sprint Run spring-assisted model features carbon fiber handle scales, a drop point style blade in a stonewash finish and the 3-way reversible pocket clip is designed for tip up carry or tip down carry only on the traditional side of the handle. Yet the effectiveness of the knife relies on several factors and one of them is the blade steel. [12] Almström, Linda, and Camilla Söderström. Check on Amazon. I think M390 a better steel than S45VN. However, M398 does have some positive traits, such as increased hardness and reduced retained austenite relative to M390: An increase in hardness and reduction in retained austenite makes me believe that the amount of chromium in solution has been reduced, learn why chromium in solution matters for hardness in this article on Vanax steel. best. See the datasheet here. “High chromium and carbide rich tool steel made by powder metallurgi and tool made of the steel.” French Patent filed January 1, 2003. Out of stock. Eat Fish, Wear Grundens, Drink Alaskan. Timestamp. Performance profile from 325,102 user samples. I recommend seeing them as “fun” educated guesses. "The reason that the somewhat better toughness result for 20CV and M390 is puzzling is because of the significantly coarser carbide structure. RELEASE, ASSUMPTION OF RISK, WAIVER OF LIABILITY, AND INDEMNITY AGREEMENT By purchasing or receiving any item produced by Spyderco, Inc., the owner assumes the responsibility to research and comply with all applicable federal, state, local, and international laws related to the possession, ownership, carry, shipment, transport, and use of any Spyderco product. Please Like, Share, Subscribe, and Turn On Notifications. So many variables come into play with these tests. [2] Pinnow, Kenneth E., William Stasko, and John Hauser. We would expect this to lead to a significant reduction in toughness along with an increase in wear resistance. The more carbide a steel has the better the wear resistance and the worse the toughness is. Thanks to Michael Poor and Connor Kaspar for becoming Knife Steel Nerds Patreon supporters! The Para 3 is a more compact version of Spyderco's immensely popular Paramilitary 2. Tungsten was very expensive and only available to mine in of the 6 th International Tooling Conference, Karlstad, Sweden. Bohler has recently released a new stainless powder metallurgy steel – M398, I first learned about it here. >> See knives with CPM-S35VN steel. Triple has a super trapper in M398 for sale on his site. What would approximate working hardness be for S145V for light use knives? We don’t stock M390 but we can make a knife out of M390. None have been carried or cut, just flipped to varying degrees. SPEED RANK: 70 th / 651. CPM S35VN is a martensitic stainless steel designed to offer improved toughness over CPM S30V. S35vn vs m390. Kershaw Knockout 1870CFM390 Carbon Fiber M390. While steels have their own attributes, it seems the m390 would hold longer edge. The toughness of S110V was estimated using its reported carbide volume as no toughness numbers are available. I saw a Youtube rope test video between the two blade steel's and I tell you what. Vanadium carbide gives more wear resistance for a given amount of carbide, and the total carbide content controls toughness to an extent. You can read more about powder metallurgy and its history in this article. I am not seeing a huge difference that would justify the cost difference between the two.
2020 s45vn vs m390