21 Jan 2020 --- Eighty four percent of UK ice cream parlors report that vanilla is their best-selling ice cream flavor, according to a survey conducted by the Ice Cream and Artisan Food Show. The second and third most popular flavors were Mint Chocolate Chip (20 percent) and Chocolate (18 percent). If you’re a serious vanilla lover—the kind of person that keeps multiple bottles of extract in their pantry—add Whole Foods’ 365 Everyday Value vanilla ice cream to your cart. Via wholefoodsmarket.com. This ice cream tasted of real vanilla beans (not vanilla flavoring—there is a difference). These scoops were well balanced: sweet but not cloying, flavorful but not overwhelming.